They can both destroy your Customer Experience
Have you ever put down the newspaper on the sofa, only to come back a half an hour later and discover someone’s left their magazine and a box of crackers right next to it?
Ever leave your shoes in the dining room after a hard day at work, and discover three other pairs and a pair of socks decided they belonged there, too?
Do you live in a neighborhood where one neighbor mows his lawn Saturday at seven-thirty like clockwork, and by ten a.m. everybody else feels like a lazy bum so they’re out there mowing, even when the grass hasn’t grown an inch?
They’re opposite sides of the same coin. Police call it the broken window theory, suggesting that one broken window in a neighborhood can start the neighborhood on a downhill spiral. Happens at home, in your neighborhood, even at work. The optimist’s version is the flowerbed theory… you get the picture.
Probably, you didn’t get this picture:

The free candy truck. Good thing they didn’t put the company name on it—where would the graffiti fit?
To follow up on last week’s outdoor lesson, I sadly deliver this charmless photo, shot in my apartment complex. My neat, orderly, suburban apartment complex. This, folks, is the truck of the landscapers who were hired to do some work on the courtyard in front of my building.
That is my car in the foreground. Which I moved away from this truck when I discovered it was to be left there overnight, from fear that it might encourage an otherwise law-abiding person, somewhere in the complex, to lose their head and graffiti something near this blight. Like, say, my car. Irrational, I know, to think that an urge to create graffiti could rub off on folks who see this. I felt silly moving the car. But maybe not quite nuts, if you believe in the broken window theory.
Okay, okay, I’ll get to the point. And it’s not what you think.
I’m not going to pick on the landscaping company for having such a nasty truck and such obvious disregard for the image their company is projecting.
There’s no name on the van, people. I don’t think they’re trying to project an image. That might be too highfalutin’ for them. They don’t need no stinkin’ image!
I’m not here to teach you an MCE lesson about what your trucks should look like, nor about keeping things clean forgoodnesssake. We’ll do that on other days.
This isn’t about respecting the rest of the world enough to park in an isolated spot if you are the unfortunate victim of a drive-by graffitiist.
This is about you.
Specifically, who you choose to hire. Because, dear reader, about a week earlier, I saw this truck in front of the main office of my apartment complex. (I mean, free candy. Who forgets that?)
The people who emerge from this van were there to pitch their services. To get hired to take care of the appearances of a very large apartment complex—issues that are too large, apparently, for the six full-time maintenance staff to handle. Big issues of aesthetics… and even though the thought of their taking care of aesthetic issues is alarming, we’re still not quite to my point.
My point.
Don’t hire these people. They may take care of you, their customer, with the lowest bid (I hope there was some half-baked reason for hiring them), but you are not taking care of your customers. To make your customers worry about riff-raff and vandalism while claiming you are making improvements is gross neglect of your customers, and pretty gross neglect of your senses.
No excuses for their occupation or anything else. I don’t want to hear it, because it’s bulls**t. There are plenty of landscapers who can do better, and in fact I’m not sure I’ve seen any who can do worse.
Don’t hire people like this, or you have entirely missed the Maximum Customer Experience boat. You’ve just broken your own window.
Grow and be well,
Kelly Erickson













15 September 2009, 8:31 am
A) – Just reading about the broken window theory in “The Tipping Point” — great book, and highly recommended. By simply cleaning up the subway, painting over graffiti on the train cars, and publicly arresting fare beaters, NY crime went down by something like 75% in the 90s. Amazing.
B) – In Canada there’s a lawn maintenance company called “The Weed Man” (no joke). You get the same teenagers and young twenty-somethings who love to be dirty and hang out with the boys and drop f-bombs all day. But they’re dressed up in uniforms, which (i) makes them appear a bit more respectable and (ii) probably makes them act a bit more respectable, at least around others. Kind of like your point, but in reverse.
BTW, did the boys on your job give you any candy?
~Graham
15 September 2009, 8:38 am
Graham,
They’ve left me so speechless I forgot to ask for my free candy.
I am the only person on the planet who doesn’t own a copy of The Tipping Point. Shameful, I know. I first learned about the broken window theory in a 1990s book on… wait for it… homekeeping (cleaning your house). It’s so easy to see that a towel dropped on the bathroom floor has the same effect as that broken window (or in reverse, the flowerbox in the neighborhood, the cleanup in Times Square)—I never forgot the lessons.
I prefer my point in reverse. Give me The Weed Man any day over Free Candy!
Truck’s back today. My skin’s crawling again. Eeeeek. Must drive away quickly…
Regards,
Kelly
15 September 2009, 11:57 am
This is exactly why I listened to James when he told me if I wanted to go professional I needed to make my site look more professional, even if it cost me money I didn’t have.
And wow, am I ever glad I did! The image Men With Pens created has shaped my whole business from that point on.
Alex Fayle | Someday Syndrome´s latest blog… No, I Won’t Talk to You: Why Someday Syndrome Offers Email-Based Coaching
15 September 2009, 12:04 pm
Speaking of Grafitti.
In Ottawa, if there’s grafitti on your property, (whether it’s your home or business), YOU’RE responsible for cleaning it up.
If you don’t, the City of Ottawa will fine you.
Never mind that they can’t enforce the law and discourage the vandals, it’s apparently YOUR fault.
(How’s THAT, for encouraging small businesses?)
Friar´s latest blog… A Single Person’s Open Letter of Apology to Parents
15 September 2009, 12:11 pm
@Friar – Is this the same city that criminalized panhandling? Wonder how they are supposed to get the money to pay their fines…
~Graham
15 September 2009, 2:15 pm
Alex,
“The image Men With Pens created has shaped my whole business from that point on.”
Shaping your whole business—that is the nicest compliment ever. I hope James appreciates that kind of word-of-mouth. And naturally, I completely agree. Men With Pens know microbusiness like nobody’s business.
Friar,
Okay, so let me see. The alternatives are:
—*not* requiring them to clean up
—requiring them to, but putting no teeth in it and hoping everybody sees it the government’s way;
—making the vandals do the cleanup (for the 2% that get caught) and letting the rest go, not making anyone clean up. The broken window stays and Ottawa goes the way of the Bronx or Detroit or Chicago, engulfed in gang messages and blight.
On this one, dear Friar, I can’t see it the way you do. If Ottawa wants to stay on top of a problem like that, they’ve got to compel the business owners to deal with it.
(This isn’t as bad as it sounds. A couple of coats of anti-graffiti paint—yes, it exists—and nobody will be able to leave a mark on the building. But that proactive measure, they’re not requiring. So if folks want the gov’t off their back, there’s a way…)
BTW, when I was in Ottawa in July, I did notice that even compared to my beloved TO it was one clean city. So the measures they’re taking are working.
Graham,
Perhaps they can get the money from cleaning the graffiti of small business owners’ buildings? *ahem*
Until later,
Kelly
15 September 2009, 2:29 pm
@ Kelly/Alex – Okay, that kind of stuff makes me blush and shit, so cut it out. (Don’t listen to me; keep saying nice stuff!) But I do grin every time I think of the first time I saw the old yellow site…
@ Kelly – You are the second person not to have read the Tipping Point.
@ Graham – The Weed Man sounds cool. I would call it The Weed Team and totally play up every inch of it. (Minus *that* kind of weed.)
Re: the van. I see this shit all the time. BIG vans. No logo. A bumper sticker. NICE trucks. No logo. Some small script in their window. BIG businesses. A crappy business card.
Stupid. Really.
James Chartrand – Men with Pens´s latest blog… We Like Special Announcements. Here are Three.
15 September 2009, 2:30 pm
Kelly
Sounds good, in theory.
But not when you read the stories in the paper, of businesses or homeowners, spending thousands a year, which they often can’t afford, to paint over the vandalism.
Again. And Again. And Again.
And then getting harassed by City By-Law inspectors, threatened them with fines, when it’s not done soon enough.
Sure, make the VICTIMS pay for the crime.
That, to me, is like saying an assualt victim “had it coming” because they dressed provocatively.
Oh well. On this one, we’ll have to disagree.
Friar´s latest blog… A Single Person’s Open Letter of Apology to Parents
15 September 2009, 2:53 pm
James,
I was gonna read it… I read bits of it in the bookstore and actually enjoyed it… but I dig in my heels when things become sensations. I won’t jump on the bandwagon! I won’t!
On the other hand, I do read him on the www and watch him on TED with great interest. I think he’s a genius. I just have this teeny-weeny stubbornness problem I have to work on.
Friar,
Paint it once with anti-graffiti paint. Done. It’s a simple wash after that. No thousands, no tales of woe in the paper.
& wandering off on the tangent for just a sec, blaming the victim is alive and well. I haven’t had that particular experience, but I do know the tactic is not on the wane in the legal system.
Having said that, I do not think it’s the same.
Who will care enough about the image of the city to keep up appearances if not the business class, who wants your/my money?
And what does it say about pride in your business and regard for your customers if you don’t want them to see a clean building that doesn’t give them fears about your neighborhood’s safety when they come to plunk down dollars on your counter? Same as this landscaping company (and my complex management), I’d say. A big eff-you, give me your money anyway.
Um, yep. We’ll have to politely disagree on this one.
Later,
Kelly
15 September 2009, 3:04 pm
Hm. Not sure how I feel about the debate, but I’ll toss in something different.
Graffiti problems in school. Solution? Invite the graffiti artists to paint a mural. Give them something to be proud of.
Results? One awesome paint job for a school wall and one gang of artists proud to defend their work. Plus, recognition for who they are.
What to people who vandalize want? Recognition. Attention. SOMEthing. Find that something, solve the problem, and you have one clean city.
In theory, sounds nice. Might even be a grain of truth to it.
James Chartrand – Men with Pens´s latest blog… We Like Special Announcements. Here are Three.
15 September 2009, 3:18 pm
Ooh, what a segue for me to hype something I love!
Believe it or not, James, that’s exactly how Philadelphia deals with the issue.
Our fair city is covered in some of the most beautiful art because the Philadelphia Anti-Graffiti Network and their Mural Arts Program saw a way to turn the problem into an opportunity. The pictures on this site do not do justice to how jaw-droppingly beautiful these murals are.
One clean city. And world-renowned for it, too.
Until later,
Kelly
15 September 2009, 4:43 pm
Or…how about making the punishment for vandalism severe enough, that it discourages anyone from trying it?
Or…if you catch someone defacing your property, you have carte blanche, to deal with the perp as you see fit? (I know what I’d like to do, if I caught a punk spray-painting my fence!)
Friar´s latest blog… A Single Person’s Open Letter of Apology to Parents
15 September 2009, 4:45 pm
Well… I don’t know. The punishment for murder is pretty severe but people *still* do that. I don’t think you can always prevent everyone, you know?
James Chartrand – Men with Pens´s latest blog… We Like Special Announcements. Here are Three.
15 September 2009, 10:27 pm
Friar,
Though it would make a very funny Friar-blog-post, I am not going to think too hard about the young kids (some of whom will rehabilitate themselves) whose midnight moment of stupidity and yes, disregard for the law, would turn into a horror show at your irate hands. I pity them!
James,
That’s pretty darned wise.
I think I should now tiptoe out softly.
Later,
Kelly